fix(applet): signaling_bitmap reflects actual AD capability (M2F.1)

Replaces the hardcoded 0x0005 in Table 8-11 with a computed value:
- Bit 2 (step-up AID SELECT required) is always set — our architecture
  always uses split AID (5501 expedited + 5502 step-up) so the channel
  is always advertised, even when no AD is present.
- Bit 0 (AD retrievable) is set only when hasAccessDocument() AND
  isAccessDocumentVerified() — we don't advertise a capability we
  can't deliver. The "finalized but not verified" branch is defensive
  (post-M2A.3 finalize requires verify) but matches the contract.

Tests in AliroAppletAuth1Test:
- auth1_bitmap_adNotProvisioned_returns0x0004 (replaces the old
  "all-zero" expectation — bit 2 is now always on)
- auth1_bitmap_adProvisionedButNotVerified_returns0x0004 (new;
  uses markAccessDocumentFinalizedForTesting without
  markAccessDocumentVerified)
- auth1_bitmap_adProvisionedAndVerified_returns0x0005 (the previous
  M2A.3 case, now correctly gated on the verified flag)

Tests run: 147, Failures: 0, Errors: 3 (pre-existing GCM only).
This commit is contained in:
michael
2026-06-17 16:54:45 -07:00
parent 0c7d4c642e
commit ed316102bf
2 changed files with 66 additions and 35 deletions

View File

@@ -795,7 +795,8 @@ public class AliroApplet extends Applet {
* credential_PubK), per §8.3.3.4.2 + ref [12]) when command_parameters * credential_PubK), per §8.3.3.4.2 + ref [12]) when command_parameters
* bit 0 = 0, or {@code 0x5A credential_PubK} (full uncompressed 65B) * bit 0 = 0, or {@code 0x5A credential_PubK} (full uncompressed 65B)
* when bit 0 = 1. Then {@code 0x9E UD_signature} and a 2-byte * when bit 0 = 1. Then {@code 0x9E UD_signature} and a 2-byte
* all-zero {@code 0x5E signaling_bitmap}. * {@code 0x5E signaling_bitmap} reflecting step-up capability and
* AD retrievability (see inline comment at the bitmap emit).
*/ */
private short buildTable811Plaintext( private short buildTable811Plaintext(
byte auth1CmdParams, CredentialStore store, byte auth1CmdParams, CredentialStore store,
@@ -824,31 +825,35 @@ public class AliroApplet extends Applet {
p += rawSigLen; p += rawSigLen;
// 0x5E 0x02 [signaling_bitmap] — 16-bit big-endian. Bit 0: Access // 0x5E 0x02 [signaling_bitmap] — 16-bit big-endian. Bit 0: Access
// Document retrievable. Bit 2: retrieval requires step-up AID SELECT // Document retrievable from this credential. Bit 2: retrieval
// (applicable on NFC). Other bits unused in v1 (no mailbox/notify). // requires step-up AID SELECT (applicable on NFC). Other bits unused
// in v1 (no mailbox/notify).
// //
// We emit 0x0005 (bits 0 + 2) when an Access Document is provisioned. // Bit 2 is always set: our architecture always uses split AID
// Honest reading of the spec would say we should leave these off // (5501 expedited + 5502 step-up), so any AD retrieval will go
// until Step-up Phase is actually implemented (CBOR + mdoc + ENVELOPE // through SELECT ACCE5502. We advertise the step-up channel even
// + GET RESPONSE + AES-GCM over StepUpSK, §8.4), but empirically the // when nothing's there yet — readers that don't speak step-up just
// closed-source ACWG_processAUTH1ResponsePayload() in X-CUBE-ALIRO's // won't try.
// Aliro.a errors out when bits 0 + 2 are clear and AD is provisioned //
// -- it expects "AD present" to be advertised. The bits are // Bit 0 reflects whether we can actually serve an AD: it requires
// informational about capabilities anyway, not enforceable // both hasAccessDocument() (finalized) AND isAccessDocumentVerified()
// commitments, so 0x0005 satisfies the vendor library. AliroApplet // (IssuerAuth check passed). Post-M2A.3 finalize requires verify so
// now returns 6D00 for any post-AUTH1 INS like 0xC9 -- StepUpApplet // the "finalized but not verified" branch is defensive — see
// at ACCE5502 handles ENVELOPE and EXCHANGE properly per spec §10.2 // CredentialStore.markAccessDocumentVerified() callers.
// + §8.4. Revisit when we test against more readers and can lean on //
// the spec literally. // Historical note: M1 hardcoded 0x0005 because the closed-source
short bitmap = 0; // ACWG_processAUTH1ResponsePayload() in X-CUBE-ALIRO's Aliro.a errors
if (store.hasAccessDocument()) { // out when bits 0 + 2 are clear and AD is provisioned. With bit 2
bitmap |= 0x0001; // bit 0 // now always set we still keep that library happy, and bit 0 only
bitmap |= 0x0004; // bit 2 — NFC requires step-up AID to fetch AD // makes a promise we can actually keep.
byte bitmapLo = 0x04; // bit 2 — split-AID step-up architecture
if (store.hasAccessDocument() && store.isAccessDocumentVerified()) {
bitmapLo |= 0x01; // bit 0 — AD retrievable
} }
out[p++] = (byte) 0x5E; out[p++] = (byte) 0x5E;
out[p++] = (byte) 0x02; out[p++] = (byte) 0x02;
out[p++] = (byte) ((bitmap >> 8) & 0xFF); out[p++] = (byte) 0x00; // high byte unused in v1
out[p++] = (byte) (bitmap & 0xFF); out[p++] = bitmapLo;
return (short) (p - outOff); return (short) (p - outOff);
} }

View File

@@ -162,8 +162,11 @@ class AliroAppletAuth1Test {
} }
@Test @Test
void auth1SignalingBitmapIsAllZeroWhenNoAccessDocProvisioned() throws Exception { void auth1_bitmap_adNotProvisioned_returns0x0004() throws Exception {
// Default setUp provisions keys but no Access Document. // Default setUp provisions keys but no Access Document. Bit 2
// (step-up AID SELECT required) is still set — the split-AID step-up
// architecture is always advertised, even when there's nothing
// behind it.
sendStandardAuth0(); sendStandardAuth0();
ResponseAPDU r = sendValidAuth1(); ResponseAPDU r = sendValidAuth1();
assertEquals(0x9000, r.getSW()); assertEquals(0x9000, r.getSW());
@@ -172,24 +175,47 @@ class AliroAppletAuth1Test {
reader.deriveExpeditedSKDevice(credentialEphemPubKey), r.getData()); reader.deriveExpeditedSKDevice(credentialEphemPubKey), r.getData());
byte[] bitmap = TlvUtil.findTopLevel(pt, 0x5E); byte[] bitmap = TlvUtil.findTopLevel(pt, 0x5E);
org.junit.jupiter.api.Assertions.assertArrayEquals( org.junit.jupiter.api.Assertions.assertArrayEquals(
new byte[] { 0x00, 0x00 }, bitmap, new byte[] { 0x00, 0x04 }, bitmap,
"no Access Document → signaling_bitmap is 0x0000"); "no Access Document → bit 2 only (0x0004); bit 0 reflects actual retrievability");
} }
@Test @Test
void auth1SignalingBitmapHasAccessDocBitsWhenAdProvisioned() throws Exception { void auth1_bitmap_adProvisionedButNotVerified_returns0x0004() throws Exception {
// Provision a non-empty Access Document via CredentialStore (bypasses // Provision opaque AD bytes and mark them finalized, but NOT verified.
// the PersonalizationApplet INS layer — that flow is tested // Post-M2A.3 the finalize flow requires IssuerAuth verify so this is a
// separately). Content is opaque here; we only care that the // defensive case — bit 0 (AD retrievable) must NOT be advertised since
// signaling_bitmap reflects presence. // we wouldn't actually serve unverified AD on the step-up path.
byte[] ad = new byte[120]; byte[] ad = new byte[120];
for (int i = 0; i < ad.length; i++) ad[i] = (byte) (i ^ 0x5A); for (int i = 0; i < ad.length; i++) ad[i] = (byte) (i ^ 0x5A);
org.junit.jupiter.api.Assertions.assertTrue( org.junit.jupiter.api.Assertions.assertTrue(
CredentialStore.get().writeAccessDocumentChunk(ad, (short) 0, (short) 0, (short) ad.length)); CredentialStore.get().writeAccessDocumentChunk(ad, (short) 0, (short) 0, (short) ad.length));
// Bypass IssuerAuth verify — opaque random bytes here, not a real
// COSE_Sign1. The signaling bitmap path only cares about the
// finalized flag, not the verified flag.
CredentialStore.get().markAccessDocumentFinalizedForTesting((short) ad.length); CredentialStore.get().markAccessDocumentFinalizedForTesting((short) ad.length);
// Deliberately do NOT mark verified.
sendStandardAuth0();
ResponseAPDU r = sendValidAuth1();
assertEquals(0x9000, r.getSW());
byte[] pt = ReaderSide.decryptAuth1Response(
reader.deriveExpeditedSKDevice(credentialEphemPubKey), r.getData());
byte[] bitmap = TlvUtil.findTopLevel(pt, 0x5E);
org.junit.jupiter.api.Assertions.assertArrayEquals(
new byte[] { 0x00, 0x04 }, bitmap,
"AD finalized but not verified → bit 2 only (0x0004); bit 0 requires verified flag");
}
@Test
void auth1_bitmap_adProvisionedAndVerified_returns0x0005() throws Exception {
// Provision a non-empty Access Document via CredentialStore (bypasses
// the PersonalizationApplet INS layer — that flow is tested
// separately). Mark both finalized AND verified to mirror the
// post-M2A.3 happy path.
byte[] ad = new byte[120];
for (int i = 0; i < ad.length; i++) ad[i] = (byte) (i ^ 0x5A);
org.junit.jupiter.api.Assertions.assertTrue(
CredentialStore.get().writeAccessDocumentChunk(ad, (short) 0, (short) 0, (short) ad.length));
CredentialStore.get().markAccessDocumentFinalizedForTesting((short) ad.length);
CredentialStore.get().markAccessDocumentVerified();
sendStandardAuth0(); sendStandardAuth0();
ResponseAPDU r = sendValidAuth1(); ResponseAPDU r = sendValidAuth1();
@@ -202,7 +228,7 @@ class AliroAppletAuth1Test {
// = 2^0 + 2^2 = 0x0005 (big-endian) // = 2^0 + 2^2 = 0x0005 (big-endian)
org.junit.jupiter.api.Assertions.assertArrayEquals( org.junit.jupiter.api.Assertions.assertArrayEquals(
new byte[] { 0x00, 0x05 }, bitmap, new byte[] { 0x00, 0x05 }, bitmap,
"Access Document provisioned on NFC → bitmap bits 0 and 2 set (0x0005)"); "AD finalized AND verified → bits 0 + 2 set (0x0005)");
} }
@Test @Test